As we begin the second half of 2024, we’ll look at three overarching themes that are currently playing out in commercial real estate in Florida.
Flight to Quality
Rates are still elevated, and transaction volume is still low. As a result, high-quality deals that come to market oftentimes enter a competitive bidding environment from lenders willing to put out dollars. Largo’s recent experience has seen the most activity from life companies, credit unions, and non-bank lenders. Volatility is still high in the banking world due to high loan-to-deposit ratios, which often results in required depository relationships for every new loan. These deposits are typically 10-20% of the loan amount; however, deposit requirements as high as 35% are not uncommon with some banks here in Florida.
With that said, strong deals are receiving competitive pricing. Recent quotes on lower-leverage multifamily and industrial have been as low as +125 bps over the corresponding Treasuries. Retail and self-storage are seeing spreads as low as +152-165 bps over the corresponding Treasuries.
Big Demand for Small Bay
Many investment firms in Florida are focused solely on the acquisition of industrial properties. More specifically, small bay industrial: those properties with a diverse mix of tenants whose spaces typically range in size from 750 to 2,500 square feet. Many of these properties are owned by “mom and pop” operators. For sponsors targeting this asset class, the business plan is essentially the same:
Identify non-institutionally owned small bay industrial assets in one of the MSAs (Miami, Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville, Sarasota, Fort Myers) with below-market rents and shorter WALTs (weighted average lease terms)
Acquire at an attractive cost basis
Mark to market rents as leases roll and then sign new NNN leases
Implement operational efficiencies to reduce expenses – this is often accomplished since many of these assets were being operated by sellers who do not have the vertical integration that many investment firms have today
Capitalize on the increase in value through either a sale or a refinance
Regarding financing, options for this business plan are usually banks, credit unions, and life companies. With banks and credit unions, terms are often structured with initial funding and either a holdback or an earnout that is achieved at certain occupancy and income thresholds. Life companies generally like to fund full dollars upfront but will also structure with holdbacks if necessary.
Each capital source has its benefits and drawbacks. Banks and credit unions tend to offer more flexible prepayment structures but often come with some level of recourse, a depository requirement, and geographic limitations on where they can lend. Life companies have more stringent prepayment structures but do not require deposits, are often non-recourse, and they can lend nationwide. Life companies can also offer terms as short as 18 months and as long as 25 years, fixed.
Insurance Still a Concern
Property insurance costs in Florida have now been a major issue for the past two years. According to CoStar, apartment insurance costs have risen by more than 300% and 150% in Fort Lauderdale and Miami, respectively. These costs are not unique to South Florida. Coastal regions including Cape Coral and the entire East Coast of Florida are feeling the same effects. Elevated insurance costs strain cash flows and adds risk to property owners seeking financing: reduced NOI leads to DSCR constraints and lower property values.
One example seen first-hand in 2023 was a new-build multifamily project on the Space Coast of Florida. Near stabilization, the sponsors were seeking a bridge loan to take out their construction lender and allow them time before a planned sale. The Year 1 insurance expense was going to be $3,400/unit. During their planning phase for the project prior to construction start, it’s likely their pro forma assumed insurance expense of $1,400/unit, or lower. This is a prime example of the situation most projects found themselves in over the past couple of years. Why is this cost increase so detrimental? Taking that $2,000/unit delta in increased expense times 300 units results in an additional $600,000 for insurance expenses. At a 5.50% cap, that’s a value loss of nearly $11M. As a borrower, the refinance options at that point are likely a cash-in refinance or bringing in subordinate debt to bridge that gap.
